March 30, 2020 A Religious and Political Commentary

How Do You Know?

Doctor to patient: “Well, I’ve got bad news and worse news. The bad news is you have 24 hours to live.”

Patient (after letting the bad news sink in): “What could be worse than that?”

Doctor: “I’ve been trying to reach you since yesterday.”

Just when you think you know what you need to know, there’s always something to learn. I’ve been thinking about this a lot recently because of conversations with my son. He is in the throes of theological education. He is a verbal processor. If you’re not sure what that means, he is the exact opposite of me! I will have a thought and I stew on it. I think quietly in order to process ideas and information – I’m a bit slow. He will have a thought and he just talks. And talks. And talks.

I won’t let a hypothesis out of my mouth I haven’t totally attempted to think-out. He’ll spout off the first thing that comes to mind. Doesn’t matter, right or wrong. In fact, I sometimes think he enjoys being wrong. Because when he’s wrong, that’s when good debate happens. And that’s how he learns. Neither learning style is right or wrong … they’re just different.

Regardless of the frustration I find with half-baked ideas, I wouldn’t trade those conversations for anything. I’m convinced he’ll surpass me in understanding soon … because he listens.

I entered the world of theological education many moons ago with a solid undergraduate background in theology. But the new ideas to which I was exposed made my head spin. I read brilliant scholars, from left and right, questioning the Book and the ideas I held sacred. Who was right? Who was wrong?

On top of this, the amount of information I was consuming and the speed at which I was learning made for quite heady days. Suddenly, I was a biblical scholar.  I was a seminarian. So many people to correct … so little time! Fortunately, these were pre “blog” days and I wasn’t preaching yet, so only my wife knows what an insufferable know-it-all I was.

Age tends to humble you. So does continued study. So does 26 years of pastoring. Just when you think you know what you need to know, there’s always something to learn.

Epistemological humility is the key. Epistemology is the idea of how we know what we know. It describes the accumulation of knowledge. Epistemological humility is gaining knowledge, and at the same time remaining humble before God and our fellow man.

It sounds simple but isn’t. We can readily see it in the history of philosophy. First, we believe in a rational God who made a rational world which could be understood by rational men (rationalism). Then, all of a sudden, we no longer believe in God. Instead, everything we need to know about our world we could objectively observe (naturalism). Then we come to realize we aren’t quite as objective as we thought … so we de-emphasize the data and re-emphasize the data collector (humanism). Ultimately, knowing seems an impossible task itself, so we just give up (post-modernism) – you can have your “facts” and I’ll have mine.

What does that mean outside of the halls of Academia? Humans will continue to advance, but those world-changing advancements of the past – the ones relating to human survival and exploration – are few and far between these days. Today’s advancements tend to gravitate toward increasing affluence and ease of life. And in the arena of the exchange of ideas, data and facts are less important than ideas and emotions. Battle-lines are drawn.

Gone are the days of debating the reasonableness, morality, or ethics of something. So, too, the days of debating the merit of ideas. Now we do what we want because we can and because we want to. Opposition to said idea becomes “phobia” or “hatred,” because the idea has been moved from being intellectual to emotional. My disagreement with you becomes personal.

Historical context is removed as well because of our “idiot delusion of the exceptional Now (in the words of John Dos Passos).” This is the idea that our time is so unprecedented that it supersedes all that has come before. Who cares what the ancients thought? Why should it matter what was done in the eighteenth century?

That’s why a failed system like socialism can make a revival in our time. It is attractive because everything will be free. We’ll make everyone economic equals, which makes us feel better. And though it has never worked elsewhere in the world, these are exceptional times. It’s bound to work in the “exceptional Now.”

What is needed is a return to epistemological humility … the kind that admits that we see through a glass darkly (1 Cor. 13:12). Each of us believes we are correct in our positions. But do we hold open the possibility that we’re wrong? Even if our conclusions are correct, is there room for error in our logic, our expression of position, or, worse, our motives? If someone disagrees with us, are they automatically enemies? Haters? Phobic? Can we even talk about it?

For me, epistemological humility means “speaking the truth in love (Eph. 4:15),” with me emphasizing “love” more than “being right.” For you, epistemological humility might mean that you understand my disagreement with you doesn’t mean I am an enemy who hates you.

 

There’s room for improvement in us all. “’Come, let us reason,’ says the Lord. (Isaiah 1:18).”

Related Posts

Religion

August 7, 2019

August 7, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestAccording to Science Daily, there are roughly 4,200 religions in the world. Make that 4,201. I realized this as I...

Here’s a handy guide to being ‘woke’ in 2019

January 3, 2019

January 3, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestSociety is evolving and the changes seem to come at breakneck pace. If you’re anything like me, you’re probably having...

Human rights campaign nothing but a bully from D.C.

September 10, 2018

September 10, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestRemember when we were up in arms about deep-pocketed outside lobbyists coming into our town telling us whether or not...

Jumping to Conclusions

January 23, 2019

January 23, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestBy now you have seen, ad nauseam, video of the “Covington Catholic Kids” and Nathan Phillips in a confrontation at...

Celebrate the good in Halloween, not the evil

October 11, 2018

October 11, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestMichael Myers is back in a new Halloween movie – a 2018 version in a long line of sequels that...

When we forgive, God forgives us

November 22, 2018

November 22, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestYou’re probably reading this column bleary-eyed from a late night of Black Friday shopping or sipping coffee in your elastic-waisted...

Perhaps solar eclipse is evidence of God’s design

August 25, 2017

August 25, 2017

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestBy the time you read this essay, the total solar eclipse of 2017 will be four days in our rear-view...

Things have changed, but what has not changed is the Bible and the U.S. Constitution

May 17, 2018

May 17, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestI love political cartoons. They combine two of my favorite things: humor and free speech. One recently caught my attention...

Willing Accomplices

March 13, 2019

March 13, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterest“No man can struggle with advantage against the spirit of his age and country, and however powerful a man may...

Today’s mob mentality similar to Luke’s description of 2,000 years ago

September 22, 2017

September 22, 2017

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestHumorist Dave Barry once said, “The problem with writing about religion is that you run the risk of offending sincerely...

Separation of Church and State?

July 17, 2017

July 17, 2017

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestRecently, the “Trinity Lutheran” case was decided favorably on behalf of the church in the US Supreme Court. “In dissent,”...

Ideas have consequences.

January 10, 2018

January 10, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestWhen Europeans began global exploration, their most surprising discoveries were not exotic lands and peoples, but their vast technological superiority...

Shame and Honor

June 7, 2017

June 7, 2017

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestHere is a Bible trivia quiz. If you have ever read Paul’s letter to the Romans, which word pair would...

If You Can Keep It

September 28, 2017

September 28, 2017

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestAs the aged Benjamin Franklin left Independence Hall in Philadelphia at the close of the Constitutional Convention in 1787, he...

A real apology should change us for the better

June 14, 2018

June 14, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestThere’s a great market in today’s culture for monetizing vulgarity.  We witnessed this recently at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner....

Comments
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *