August 25, 2019 A Religious and Political Commentary

Bible even points to idea of innocent until proven guilty

Do Americans still believe the adage that someone is innocent until proven guilty? Would you believe it was God’s idea?

When Job’s life was in turmoil, his friends assumed he had done wrong and was being divinely punished.  Many allegations were made against his character, though each was incorrect. The book ends with God chastising Job’s friends for their rush to judgment.

Even as wild allegations were made against Jesus, the legal expert Nicodemus spoke: “Does our law condemn anyone without first hearing him to find out what he is doing (John 7:51)?”

Presumption of innocence is one thing, evidence is another – and also important to God. When Israel was a new nation, learning how to pursue its own course after years of slavery, Moses instructed them in the Old Testament book of Deuteronomy.

It is more than a legal document; Deuteronomy is God’s primer on how to have a free society. God teaches the Hebrews how to treat one another, how to buy, sell, and trade fairly, how to own property and respect the property of others. God even teaches on areas of hygiene and diet.

God also instructs the nation in jurisprudence.  Conflict is bound to happen whenever people live together.  Deuteronomy 19 talks about anger, assault, and disputes over property lines.  How is society to determine who is right or wrong? Evidence.

“One witness is not enough to convict a man accused of any crime or offense he may have committed. A matter must be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses…. The judges must make a thorough investigation… (Deuteronomy 19:15, 18).” In divine wisdom, God determined the need for two witnesses rather than one to aid the discovery of truth.

This extra witness alleviates “he said / she said” and mitigates against one party lying.  Of course, two false witnesses can still conspire to lie, but the odds of getting a fair hearing are better with multiple eyewitness accounts. Still, it doesn’t always work. When wicked Queen Jezebel determined to take Naboth’s vineyard in 1 Kings 21, she did so by recruiting two “scoundrels” to perjure themselves.

Even at Jesus’ trial, the Sanhedrin heard “evidence” from multiple witnesses.  Matthew’s Gospel tells us this was “false testimony” and that many of the witnesses who came forward disagreed in their statements.  But Jesus’ enemies eventually found two “witnesses” making the same accusation, and the Sanhedrin had what they were looking for – a charge of blasphemy.

So there’s nothing magic about having more than one witness, but it is a safeguard to help arrive at the truth.

The point is that allegations of wrong-doing are not enough. Evidence is needed from multiple sources. And until the evidence is produced and judges are satisfied, the accused is presumed innocent.

As I write this, Brett Kavanaugh is “on trial” for allegations from high school. Christine Blasey Ford has alleged sexual assault at a high school party some thirty years before. An FBI report on their investigation is being reviewed by committees today. These are certainly serious charges that need to be examined.  Witnesses should be called and oaths given.  We Americans want the truth.

But there must be more than an allegation.  Evidence, not gender or political affiliation should determine the outcome. Some argue that the seriousness of the allegation is enough…or that the cost of Dr. Blasey Ford coming forward is proof of her veracity. Others shout that because Dr. Blasey Ford is a Democrat she can’t be believed. Compelling arguments…but supposition…allegation…not evidence.

American jurisprudence is built on the foundation stone of “innocent until proven guilty”…not innocent until alleged. We need facts.

But in our social-media driven world of soundbites and Tweets, the allegation itself is often enough to destroy a person’s life and career. Often, our minds are made up before a witness takes the stand.

In Denton, an award-winning teacher was recently accused of “stalking behavior.”  The Denton Record Chronicle reports no criminal charges have been filed and she has not lost her Texas teaching certificate. Still, the journalist includes “helpful” information like statistics of inappropriate teacher-student relationships in Texas, the fact that these are second-degree felonies, and the news that there’s a move in Texas to increase these penalties (though no criminal charges have been filed).

Also somehow relevant is the fact that the teacher didn’t talk to DRC reporters, referring them instead to her out-of-town attorney, and the fact that the teacher’s husband committed suicide the year before.

An inappropriate teacher-student relationship is a serious allegation…so is attempted rape. With serious allegations like these, it’s hard not to rush to judgment and think “Guilty until proven innocent!” That word “alleged” is perhaps the most invisible, overlooked word in the English language.

I don’t know about Judge Kavanaugh…or Ms. Arispe.  Guilt or innocence in these cases is not the point.  The point is that we stop rushing to judgment based on tabloid gossip simply because an allegation has been made. “The judges must make a thorough investigation… (Deuteronomy 19:18)” and let the evidence lead where it may.

Related Posts

The image of God in the bathroom at Target

May 26, 2016

May 26, 2016

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestThere’s a lot of talk in our beloved country today about bathrooms.  Arguments and emotions are at a high pitch...

Here’s a handy guide to being ‘woke’ in 2019

January 3, 2019

January 3, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestSociety is evolving and the changes seem to come at breakneck pace. If you’re anything like me, you’re probably having...

Work Brings Reward

March 29, 2019

March 29, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterest“It will never be known what acts of cowardice have been motivated by the fear of not looking sufficiently progressive.”~...

Power of God’s love disables the power of that thing we fear

November 1, 2017

November 1, 2017

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterest“The only thing we have to fear is fear itself…” The iconic line from FDR’s first inaugural address in 1933...

A real apology should change us for the better

June 14, 2018

June 14, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestThere’s a great market in today’s culture for monetizing vulgarity.  We witnessed this recently at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner....

Individual opinions have become offensive to others

July 26, 2018

July 26, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestIt is said, “Everyone has an opinion.”  In America, we take this one step further: “Everyone is entitled to an...

You’re Fired!

May 8, 2019

May 8, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestIn my 50 years, I’d never been fired. I have come awfully close, but my never-been-fired streak remained intact. Until...

Elections Matter – ALL of Them

April 11, 2019

April 11, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestOnce upon a time, in a faraway land, there were four trees.  These trees were looking for a king.  So...

Religion

August 7, 2019

August 7, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestAccording to Science Daily, there are roughly 4,200 religions in the world. Make that 4,201. I realized this as I...

Things have changed, but what has not changed is the Bible and the U.S. Constitution

May 17, 2018

May 17, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestI love political cartoons. They combine two of my favorite things: humor and free speech. One recently caught my attention...

Willing Accomplices

March 13, 2019

March 13, 2019

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterest“No man can struggle with advantage against the spirit of his age and country, and however powerful a man may...

Honesty, civility, positivity key to free speech

April 6, 2018

April 6, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterest“I do not agree with what you have to say, but I’ll defend to the death your right to say...

Human rights campaign nothing but a bully from D.C.

September 10, 2018

September 10, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestRemember when we were up in arms about deep-pocketed outside lobbyists coming into our town telling us whether or not...

Perhaps solar eclipse is evidence of God’s design

August 25, 2017

August 25, 2017

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestBy the time you read this essay, the total solar eclipse of 2017 will be four days in our rear-view...

Solutions to our opioids crisis cannot neglect the spiritual aspect of humans

October 30, 2018

October 30, 2018

FacebookTwitteremailLinkedinPinterestEaster, 2016. A sunrise service and two wonderful resurrection celebrations. Afterwards, I had Easter dinner with the family, then my...

Comments
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *